Friday, September 28, 2007

Chapter 3 - Leaping Wizards

Gaming in Arizona is thin, especially if you're into tabletop RPGs. It's a lot bigger now than it used to be when I started, but it's still a very small movement. Conventions and game stores are the places to go if you want to find a group, and there are less game stores now than there were before. All my old haunts (Michael's Magic, Waterloo, Game Knights) are closed now, and at the moment there are exactly two notable shops, down from the five I knew before.

The RPGA (Role Playing Gamers' Association) is the de facto public face of all roleplayers, as nobody really takes the Steve Jackson Games' "Men in Black" group or White Wolf's "Camarilla" seriously, and they represent games with much fewer players nationwide. It's a sort of national fan club for Dungeons & Dragons, an organized system for playing the game publicly, typically at conventions. The RPGA holds events at most conventions, where membership guarantees you a spot at a table, and your character is eligible to play in any RPGA event. The reason RPGA certification is important is that their adventures, treasures, and rules are balanced and standardized, so there's no hope your buddy DM will allow you to have major world-breaking artifacts when you bring your sheet to Gen Con.

Seems like a great idea, especially when you're between groups and looking to game. Today the conventions are jam-packed with RPGA tables, something that still surprises me when I cruise the gaming rooms. It surprises me because it wasn't always like that. When I joined the RPGA there were almost two conventions a year for gaming: Hexacon, Leprecon, and CopperCon. Only Hexacon had organized gaming; the other two claimed to have rooms for "open gaming" but nobody ever showed. Today there are two gaming conventions: Hexacon and ConGames. And ConGames sucks.

So it's rough-going if you're in Arizona. The RPGA allows sanctioned gameplay outside of conventions but it's a poor substitute for a regular group of players who aren't handcuffed to an approved adventure module and strictly limited in the treasure they can award.

I was pretty much one of the original members of the Arizona RPGA, and considering I started in the 90s, is really sad. There are a lot of gamers now, but when I volunteered to DM an RPGA event at Hexacon, we had exactly one table with four players, and one of those players was my brother. I did that for about a year, running monthly sanctioned games in the dusty back-room of Waterloo, a room without air conditioning that routinely ran over 100 degrees Fahrenheit, cooled only by an oscillating fan from the Cold War. It was the same group of people almost every time.

I think D&D 3rd Edition is what really caused the spike in membership, but I'd quit the RPGA by then so I couldn't tell you for sure. But I'm getting ahead of myself. Funny story about that game at Hexacon.

RPGA characters are based on a point-buy system instead of the normal D&D method of generating each of your attributes (like Strength, Intelligence, Charisma) by rolling three or four six-sided dice. A point-buy system gives each player an equal number of points to spend as currency on those attributes, so all characters are equal and nobody has to openly accuse another player of being a cheating swine when he brings a guy with 18s in every attribute to the table. This also has the side effect of making every character nearly identical in a class-based system.

When I gathered the four players who had signed up for my first-ever RPGA tournament module, I took a look at their character sheets just to make sure everything was kosher. I thought someone was playing a prank on me.

They were the same character. All of them.

Different names, different handwriting, exact same numbers. Apparently I wasn't aware of the AD&D fad class known as the "specialty priest," a new type of class popularized in the Forgotten Realms campaign supplements. A specialty priest is basically a cleric, but one who has unique powers and spells from the particular god she worships. So basically a specialty priest of a storm god would have a bunch of lightning spells. Things like that. I actually helped my brother create his character, and together we saw a class that was rather appealing: the Specialty Priest of Selune (goddess of the moon). These clerics were gifted with some particularly abusive spells (one I remember is the ability to conjure a sick-ass longsword made of moonlight) and combat bonuses that waxed and waned along with the phase of the moon.

Every single player had brought a specialty priest of Selune. They didn't get together and discuss it, they weren't trying to pull a scam, and they weren't even really trying to min-max. Every person had independently been flipping though the books, saw a rather unbalanced class and said to themselves "now that is badass!" Why play a normal cleric when one who worships Selune gets a +2 to-hit on a full moon?

Well, at least they all had an easy excuse to adventure together. And they certainly wouldn't be short of healing magic.

I don't remember much about the module itself. Like most RPGA modules it was boring, shallow, unnecessarily jokey, and short. They have to be shallow and jokey because it has to be appropriate for very young kids, and they have to be short because you only have four hours to finish the module, and about a half-hour of that goes into issuing certs (for magic items) and voting for the winner. If you're wondering how there can be a winner in an RPG, there can't. People just vote for the MVP and that person gets some extra experience points. It stinks, and it can really make the other players at the table feel lousy.

Anyway, I do remember one key encounter for that adventure because it stands as the most humiliated I've ever been during a game. Embarrassment like that tends to stand out in your memory. While journeying to another city, the party made camp in a small copse of trees on a hill. The module had a scripted encounter for this, wherein a group of four 1st-level Magic-Users would sneak up on their camp that night and attack. I don't think any explanation is offered for where these Magic-Users came from, what they wanted, or who they worked for, but that was the encounter.

After making surprise checks, I announced to the player on watch, "You hear a rustling from all sides of the camp. Just as you shout a warning, four robed men wielding staves leap out of the underbrush and give a shout!"

They wouldn't stop laughing for five minutes. It was (for lack of a more P.C. term) the gayest ambush in AD&D history.

That had to be demoralizing to the mages when their war cry was met with howls of derisive laughter. It was worse for me, because that stupid encounter made me look like a damn fool. In an instant I'd become the running joke of the convention when the "Leaping Wizards" incident became well-known. It was such a crappy encounter, such a pushover, and so unrealistic even for a fantasy setting that even now, a few old friends like to bring it up just to push my buttons.

Just imagine what course of events led to that: a group of four plebian magic-users, constantly picked on in their childhoods and unable to secure honest work decide to turn to a life of crime, attacking groups of heavily-armed travellers with quarterstaves and their one magic spell. Yes, one spell. First-level wizards in AD&D got one, exactly one spell to cast. These were the hardcore days, the all-or-nothing days where a wizard was a long-term investment. Until you reached about seventh level and could hurl third-level magic you were a combat liability. A first-level magic-user throws a single Magic Missile and he's blown his load for the night.

So when a group of four wizards tries to ambush a group of clerics, each throwing out 1d4 of damage as their best attack of the night, it makes me wonder how those guys can justify their 16 in Intelligence. Clerics fart more healing magic than 1d4 points. Gandalf would weep. I shouldn't have even been the one they were making fun of! What about the asshole who wrote it? I was just reading the flavor text!

My options at that point were to stop DMing or commit ritual seppuku. I decided to just burn out for a while. After all, only a few people I'd never talk to again know about it.

Oh.

Crap.




Amusing postscript to that story:

Someone asked if I was allowed to alter what spells the magic-users had when I ran the module. Well that's the thing: I changed their spell loadout so I could make the fight more competitive.

They originally came packing Magic Missiles, when instead I had them act in a much more coordinated fashion. One of them memorized Sleep, and the others memorized Ray of Enfeeblement. After hitting the group and incapacitating two of the clerics with Sleep, the other three hit the biggest-looking cleric with a trio of weakening Rays.

I nearly won that fight.

I was a little angry that they were laughing at me so I ruled that they wasted an entire round doing that. The Enfeebled cleric got utterly ganked by some lucky hits and was killed in the first round. The only thing that saved them was the only remaining cleric went around kicking his sleeping comrades in the face to wake them up.

When the regional supervisor heard what I'd done, he was furious and made me overturn my own decision to have one of the wizards deliver a deathblow to the unconscious cleric. He told me not to alter the module as written, and further, to restrain myself from inflicting any fatalities on the group. Characters in the RPGA level up slowly, so a character death can be a major thing at high levels, and almost impossible to recover from. They represent a massive investment of time. Many of the modules were written with fudge rules on how to proceed if the bad guys start to win so that the adventure can continue.

The DM is not only directed to treat the players with kid gloves, he's directed to let them win. I objected to this general practice and never really bothered DMing much for the RPGA after that. What's the point? I may have misspoken earlier when I called my days in the RPGA the "all-or-nothing" days, because I remember those old TSR tournament modules being fucking hardcore. Certainly no leaping wizards in there. Some of those tourney adventures were goddamn character meat-grinders.

No room for whiners when Gygax was in charge. Recognize.

No comments: